When Should You Avoid Using Synthetic Oil? Key Reasons & Real-World Advice
Synthetic oil isn’t perfect for every engine. Learn exactly when you shouldn’t use it, what happens if you do, and how to keep your car running strong.
When you hear conventional oil, a refined petroleum-based lubricant used in internal combustion engines. Also known as mineral oil, it's the original engine lubricant that's been keeping cars running for over a century. It’s not fancy, but it works—and for millions of drivers, it’s still the go-to choice. Unlike synthetic oil, which is chemically engineered in a lab, conventional oil comes from crude oil that’s been distilled and treated to remove impurities. It’s simpler, cheaper, and often just fine for everyday vehicles that don’t push hard or run in extreme conditions.
Most cars made before 2010 were designed with conventional oil in mind. If your owner’s manual says "use 10W-40" without specifying synthetic, you’re probably safe sticking with it. But here’s the catch: conventional oil breaks down faster. It doesn’t handle heat as well, and it thickens in cold weather more than synthetic. That means you’ll need to change it more often—usually every 3,000 to 5,000 miles—compared to 7,500 to 10,000 miles for synthetics. If you’re driving short trips in winter, or your engine runs hot because of heavy traffic, conventional oil might not give your engine the protection it needs. But if you drive gently, keep up with oil changes, and your car isn’t high-performance, it’s a perfectly valid option.
It’s also the oil you’ll find in older engines that weren’t built for modern synthetics. Some classic cars, lawnmowers, and small engines still rely on conventional oil because their seals and materials weren’t designed for the additives in synthetics. And if you’re on a tight budget, conventional oil saves you money at every fill-up. You’re not sacrificing safety—you’re just being practical. Just don’t confuse it with neglect. Skipping oil changes with conventional oil is a fast track to sludge buildup, engine wear, and costly repairs. That’s why the posts below focus on real-world oil care: how to spot when your oil is failing, what happens if you mix types, and how to tell if your engine’s screaming for a change.
What you’ll find here isn’t theory. It’s what drivers actually deal with: the signs your oil’s gone bad, why adding oil isn’t a fix, how the wrong viscosity can hurt your engine, and when it’s time to switch to something better. Whether you’re maintaining a daily driver or restoring a classic, these guides give you the facts you need to keep your engine alive without overpaying.
Synthetic oil isn’t perfect for every engine. Learn exactly when you shouldn’t use it, what happens if you do, and how to keep your car running strong.